Smash has no value for anyone who isn't already a big nintendo fan. Pokemon really isn't that mandatory. Also Madden, seriously? 3/10
Decent, but make up your mind on one of the Saints Rows. Also race games a shit. 7/10
TF2 is a terrible introduction into arena shooters. As is pokemon for RPGs unless your target audience has a fetish for grinding. You don't get much more casual than Mario Party. 5/10
Nonoe of these are good nor bad, apart from Autism Simulator maybe. 6/10
Borederlands is a chore as a single player game. Fallout 3 indeed had an incredible atmosphere but fell apart in literally every other aspect. Nevertheless one of the better lists. 7.5/10
Not too bad but two quirky platformers and 2 big-field-of-nothing-with-quests games, rather bland. You're lucky I didn't play that KH game. 6/10, 4/10 if KH:DDD is as bland as gigolo said
Aside from these, TF2, Pokemon and Rugby League video games, I haven't played much, so that's really all I can recommend.
That said, I like the PS3 Ratchet and Clank games too, but they aren't as much of a symbol as say UYA.
Can't even make his own list, 0/10
Wow more like WOOOOOOW NO. At least you picked a good arena shooter and one of the better pokemon games. 7/10
too poor to buy games as a kid and was forced to play shovelware like earthworm jim. Already said what I said about smash, tf2 and autism sim. 5.5/10 because I pity your terrible childhood
Definitely thought this through but recommending ancient games because they are ancient is a bad move. 8/10