Been playing Fallout 4 (Not giving my money to Beth edition) and gotta say, its really a "good game, terrible Fallout".
The entire RPG element got thrown out of the window. Your character already has a written past, personality and voice. Makes it hard to get invested on it or feel like you are playing with YOUR character.
The lack of skills and skill checks annoy me. It was a pillar of the franchise for almost 2 decades, now your character cant be a nerd that bypasses quests or helps people because he had a high Medicine skill, he is just a grunt that shoots people and loots stuff.
Which makes me say, this was the first game which I downloaded mods pretty much after starting, because of how ASS the dialogue system is.
Instead of the menu with several choices you had in every other game, its now the Mass Effect like menu with only 4 choices: Question, Yes/Positive, Maybe/Sarcasm, No/Negative.
And the worst of all, the option doesnt tells you what your character is going to say. A couple of times I choose an option only for the dumbass to yell something different.
Really limited weapon choices. I get that crafting is the big thing, but wow, Fallout New Vegas had 20 different pistols (both bullet and energy, excluding unique counterparts), while 4 has 15 (both kinds, also excluding counterparts), with 6 of these being both in the 'pistol' and 'rifle' category, depending on the parts you put.
And talking about crafting, I hate the crafting in this game. It forces you to hoard EVERY junk you find around, because everything has crafting components.
Still a great shooter though. If I didnt had played any other Fallout, I would have liked it more.